According to The Conversation Project, 92% of Americans think it’s important to discuss their wishes for end-of-life care, but only 32% have done it. As you consider the unknowns about your future health and decisions that might need to be made on your behalf, it’s essential that you reflect on your values and how they relate to your preferences for treatment. This reflection prepares you to talk about your priorities with those on your healthcare team and to write them down in an advance healthcare directive.
Ideally, you will also choose a healthcare decision maker (also called your “healthcare agent”) and talk about your thoughts with this person. Don’t force yourself to complete this conversation in one sitting. That could be overwhelming. And keep in mind that over the years, as your health and life circumstances change, you will want to update your advance directive and your healthcare decision maker through new discussions. Talking about your values may even draw you closer to the person you have chosen to make decisions on your behalf.
The end goal of these conversations is to provide guidance to anyone who needs to make decisions when you are unable to do so. But the conversations are also much bigger than that.
It’s about living While life support issues are a part of the discussion, it’s not just about death and dying. In some ways, this is a great time to think about what is important to you about living and how you might make adjustments so your life is more in alignment with your priorities.
These conversations are not just for people with a serious illness. Every adult needs to make their wishes known—before it’s too late. You never know. Realistically, something could happen even today that might render you unable to speak for yourself in a health crisis.
Before engaging in conversation about your healthcare wishes, do some personal reflection about what matters most to you. What brings joy to your days? Meaning to your life? For instance, you might wish to consider the following:
Your “bucket list.” With whatever time you have left, be it weeks, months, or years, is there anything you really hope to do, see, or say before your time is done?
What makes a good day good? Your answers will provide clues for yourself and others concerning what to prioritize in your daily life. That is, if others had to be in charge of your life, what should they focus on providing for you?
What makes a bad day bad? Are there things that are important to you to avoid or control? For instance, nausea from chemotherapy. Or certain characteristics in care providers (perfume, loud voice, etc.). Share this information with your loved ones and your healthcare team. Ask for their help.
Is there anything that might be “worse than death”? For some, it might be a life of unrelenting pain. For others, it would be immobility or dementia so advanced they can’t recognize their family or friends. Each of us has our own unique threshold of acceptable quality of life.
You may have a general sense of where you are on this continuum of priorities. There is no right or wrong. And there is plenty of middle ground in between. Which of these statements is closest to how you would feel if you were seriously ill?
“As long as there is hope, do everything you can to keep me alive.”
“If my day-to-day quality of life gets too low, I would prefer to be kept comfortable and peacefully let nature take its course.”
How might you change these statements to more closely reflect your feelings? Follow your gut with what feels true for you. Let your doctor, your family, and your healthcare decision maker know where you land on this continuum.
More and more, medicine is adopting the principles of “patient-centered care” and “shared decision making.” Rarely does the doctor tell the patient what to do. Instead, in the ideal relationship, patient and doctor work together to decide on a care plan that helps the patient live according to their own values and priorities.
Consider for yourself: Do you prefer to be involved in all care decisions? To know all the details? Or would you prefer that a doctor choose, or that those close to you work with a doctor to decide on your course of treatment? Again, there is no right or wrong. It’s simply a matter of your own personal preference. Where do you fall on this continuum:
“Please include me in all decisions. Tell me about lab tests and let me know the diagnosis. Explain all my options in detail, including the pros and the cons. Be honest with me about my chances of living or dying. Also my likely quality of life with each type of treatment.”
“I prefer that others take the lead. Make the decisions you think are best based on what you know of my values and priorities. I don’t need details. What I need most is your help staying upbeat and positive.”
How might you modify these statements? Share your thoughts with your healthcare decision maker, your doctor, and your family.
The topics of these conversations are often the groundwork for a time when your healthcare decision maker may need to answer questions about life support measures. Understanding your priorities about quality and quantity of life will be important. It will also be important to weigh the likely outcomes of the different treatments; for instance, cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR), ventilators (mechanical breathing machines), and artificial nutrition (tube feeding). It will help your healthcare decision maker to talk with you now about each of these life support measures. Once you know the survival rates, the likelihood of brain damage, whether you are likely to be able to live independently afterward, you can give your healthcare decision maker a better sense of which treatments you are likely to want or not want.
If you are a family caregiver hoping to bring up the subject with a loved one These are big topics and not always easy to bring up with a parent or other relative—especially if you live out of the area and don’t see them regularly. Plus, there may be different generational norms about conversations concerning death or dying. Unless there is a serious illness, they may not want to talk about such issues.
Going slowly—talking about different topics over time—is often the wisest approach (versus one mega conversation). You might use a “soft start,” commenting on a health issue in the news or a friend’s illness and treatment. Ask your family member about their thoughts. Bit by bit, start building greater comfort with the topics.
A bucket list conversation is often a light-hearted way to start. Consider watching “The Bucket List” movie with Jack Nicholson and Morgan Freeman. This comedy allows for some silliness and laughter as a segue to a more serious discussion. Besides, why not share your bucket list? Who knows! This might spark a fun adventure and create an enduring memory.
Even a conversation about what matters most in life can often be introduced fairly lightly, enabling you to introduce larger issues gradually.
A direct talk about death or end-of-life care. This topic is usually the hardest. Once everyone gets past the initial discomfort, though, most families are relieved to have the issues out in the open. Here are some prompts that might help:
A friend’s experience. “My friend’s father just died. It sounds like it was really hard on the family, mostly because they didn’t know what he wanted in terms of treatment at the end. Everyone had a different idea of what should be done. And where he should be. They couldn’t agree. It made a tough situation worse. It occurs to me, I don’t really know what your thoughts are. Should we do everything to keep you alive, or would you rather not be at the hospital? What are your preferences?”
Creating your own advance directive. “I was putting together an advance healthcare directive for myself. This way, my doctor will know what I want in terms of life-support treatment if I am, say, in an accident. You never know. Something could happen tomorrow! I was wondering, what do you think about CPR? Or ventilators (breathing machines)?”
Being a good son/daughter. “I have something on my mind I’ve been wanting to ask you, but it’s kind of uncomfortable to talk about. Still, I feel like we should. I wouldn’t be a good son/daughter if I didn’t find out about your wishes concerning end-of-life care. You might not be able to speak for yourself. It would help me now to know what your preferences are so we can be sure they are followed.”
A news story. Find something that comes up in the news. It could be about a problem due to a lack of directive. (For past cases in the news, Google “Nancy Cruzan” or “Karen Quinlan.”) Conversely, you might talk about the advantages of planning ahead and letting your wishes be known. For instance, “Did you know that Senator John McCain died peacefully at home? No hospital? No tubes or machinery?” The same is true for Senator Ted Kennedy as well as Presidents Ronald Reagan and George H.W. Bush.
Responding to resistance Here are some common ways people tend to deflect when someone brings up the subject of advance directives and end-of-life decisions:
“It’s too painful to talk about. Besides, talking about it is bad luck.”
Don’t challenge this belief. Respectfully acknowledge your loved one’s discomfort with the subject. Then try sharing that you are distressed at the prospect of the guilt you will feel if you are called upon to make decisions on their behalf, wondering if you made “the wrong decision.” Suggest the two of you come back to the subject in a few days. Planting the seed and letting the subject rest gives your loved one some time to get used to the idea.
“It’ll be okay. I’ll beat this thing. We don’t need to discuss life support.”
Denial is one of many ways people cope with problems that seem overwhelming. It can be a very important strategy for a person who is facing a serious illness. Still, you do need to know their wishes. Try framing your need for a conversation in the context of “just in case.” In a gesture of unity, you could offer to work on your own e same time they work on theirs. Everyone needs an advance directive.
“It’s all in God’s hands.”
Those who are religious may believe the moment of death is out of our control. Whether or not you agree with these beliefs, you can affirm your relative’s conviction and still point out that “God has given us the responsibility to determine how we live up until death.” Then you can share your need to know more about your family member’s wishes.
Consider a family discussion
Instead of focusing on one person’s specific wishes, you might initiate a discussion in which everyone shares their wishes. Everyone is entitled to their own desires. It’s not a debate. But each of you sharing your thoughts lets everyone know who leans more toward lots of intervention with a focus on length of life, and who leans more toward minimal intervention with more quality of life. It also removes the sensitivity of one person being on the hot spot and acknowledges that we all have to address these issues.
Arizona Care Management solutions is an exceptional resource for elders. I have referred to this company for decades because they are ethical, knowledgable and reputable. For families and their loved ones they offer safe, personalized and secure solutions that are essential for families and their loved ones during periods of transition. They are familiar with local resources and will find the right solution for your unique needs. Beware of inferior company’s claiming to be elder care advisors. They may lack the expertise, credentials, ethics and knowledge that families need in a time of crisis. I highly recommend Bonnie Shimko and her team! Sincerely, Mary T. Pearson owner, Harmony Home Care
I owned an assisted-living home in Prescott Valley, for eight years and I had many clients who unfortunately did not have family local to help them with their finances or did not have the knowledge needed to properly prepare and budget for the outrageous cost of Care needed for a loved one or themselves. AZ Care Management helped several of my clients navigate challenging systems like long-term healthcare insurance, in-home care and The most complicated Arizona Long Term Care System (ALTCS). Bonnie and her incredibly compassionate team were always there for the client no matter how small or how great their needs were they truly were there until the very end, ensuring a peaceful transition with support and guidance for the families through every step. I would highly recommend AZ Care Management services to anyone who needs help navigating the complicated system of healthcare while aging.
Our family of 5 children was beyond frustrated. We could not convince my mother to move to the facility she herself had picked out and home was no longer a safe option. Stephanie was an angel who formed a caring relationship with mom and maintained her dignity and self esteem during the transition. She went above and beyond what was expected, and we all heeded her advice. I honestly don't know what we would have done without Arizona Care Management! (And I am a nurse!)
I have both professional and personal experience with Arizona Care Mngmt. Their team is excellent from the first phone call through receiving services. Each team member displays professionalism, respect and an obvious care for those they work with. I strongly recommend trusting this team with your own care and those you care for.- Bonnie Pond, Occupational Therapist
Amazing service!! Always willing to help and all caregivers I worked with were very nice, respectful and knowledgeable. Bonnie is a wealth of knowledge is all things related to this business of caring for elderly. My last caregiver assigned to my Aunt was Rick!!! He is amazing and very accommodating. He went above and beyond to help us both while on hospice services. He always communicated with me and kept me informed of any changes in Joyce's condition.
Gina has been extremely helpful in managing difficult situations with my mother who insists on aging out of state, far from any family members. She keeps my sister and me informed and allows for our peace of mind. She truly cares about my mother's well-being!
ACMS and Bonnie Shimko are literal dreams come true and I can't overstate that. This group of humans are truly everything. Looking after two ailing parents by myself for a while, I'd daydream about finding a competent and kind group to help me navigate that ever-complicating world. I was in charge of meds, safety, doc visits, clinic visits, short term/long term health goals and a hurricane of worries too numerous to mention. I searched everywhere, I tried different places... in every single outfit, caregiving was a task prone to slip-ups like any profession. However, my parents health is not a task to be completed- it's a living, changing reality. It's a newborn that requires constant monitoring and adjustments. Bonnie (as well as Leoni & Andrea) are so far beyond competent and kind that it makes my head spin on a weekly basis. Each one is as engaged as a family member. They attend every doc, hospital or clinic visit, they organise & automate meds and they're prompt & lovely. We had some recent ER and hospital stays and they showed up like my parents were the most important people in the world. I can't say enough about these folks, obviously. I love them. I would ABSOLUTELY spend my days worried if I didn't have them in my corner. If you'd worried you'd never find the kind of care your parents deserve- congratulations, it exists. The craziest part? I'd sell my stuff to look after my dad... yet I can't believe how modestly they charge for this level of care. I tell ya... dream come true.
My sisters and I were struggling with living in different states than our parents, and wanting our parents to continue living in the home that they built together. Our father is experiencing dementia and our mother is his caretaker, but is also declining in health. Bonnie and her team have been instrumental in allowing them to continue to stay at home by coordinating care for our mother. They attend appointments, assist with transportation, and communication for us. Bonnie is a fabulous resource for knowing providers, home care agencies, and other resources in the community. During Covid she was instrumental in getting our mother treatment in the hospital and being her advocate we none of our family was able to be with her. Bonnie has gone above and beyond several times. I truly don't know what we would do without Bonnie and her team. I don't think mom and dad would be able to be in their home. I could not recommend Arizona Care Management Solutions more.
When it became clear my mom was rapidly declining due to alzheimer's, and in an unsafe living situation, finding Bonnie from AZ Care Management Solutions was a literal God-send to our family. For months, we were beating our heads against a wall, as we had no idea how to proceed, searching for answers, as we were battling a very controlling/abusive husband as well. When we finally found Bonnie, she took a personal interest in my mom. She listened to our issues. She gave us direction, advice and calmed our hearts with her care and expertise. The very next day she was at my mom's home assessing the situation. She then took the time to work with us on a rapid plan of escape for mom. Bonnie then coordinated, and was on scene with us with APS and PD during the rescue. After getting mom to safety, Bonnie directed us to excellent legal counsel for mom's finances, getting her the best care possible, and ensuring all was legal from her escape to conservator/guardianship. Bonnie's knowledge, experience in this arena and love for others made her and AZ Care Management Solutions a literal life saver for my mom.Since my mom needed 24 hour care, we put her in a very nice care home, and hired Gina from AZ Care Mgmt Solutions as an advocate, who also has a heart for others, and has been seeing my mom twice a week to check on her status, entertain, play games, paint fingernails, coordinate outings, etc. This take tremendous pressure off of us, who can't get there as often. Gina also has natural ability and experience to relate and connect with alzheimer's patients that we don't. My mom loves Gina, and would not have adjusted nearly as well to the change without Gina's help.Thank you and God Bless all of you at AZ Care Management Solutions.
I have been with Arizona Care Management Solutions 6 years and I love the company, my caregivers have been great and so helpful going out of their way to help.
AZ Care Management Solutions sponsored a caregiver day of renewal on 5/6/23. A vendor fair, chair massages, and presentations along with a light breakfast, lunch and giveaways were included. Thank you!
After my mom fell and broke her hip, I was alone in trying to figure out how to best care for her in this maze of what is the senior health care industry.I had been trying to pull together what felt like 1000 pieces of disparate information......places to see, insurance companies, doctors to call, forms to be filled out, questions to answer. I was completely overwhelmed and under much stress.I am so incredibly thankful that I finally called Bonnie and scheduled a consultation. She was clear, knowledgable and so understanding. She immediately started making phone calls to find out the answers to some of my questions, and knew the answers to the other ones.I ended up asking her for further help and I will be forever grateful I did.She helped me move through a very difficult time with her knowledge, presence and help. She was there when I needed her and she knew exactly what to do. And she is fair, compassionate and has great integrity.My mom is now in a perfect place for her, and it all happened with as much ease as was possible.Thank you Bonnie, and everyone else we interacted with at AZ CareManagement.I don't know how I would have managed this journey without you.
Bonnie and Bob at Arizona Care Management went way above and beyond in helping me place my sister in a care facility to live out her last few months. Bonnie set up a medical transport from Newport Oregon to Arizona so that my sister could spend her final days looking at the beautiful scenery she cherished so much as a park ranger. The home in Cottonwood was well staffed and professionally managed and Bonnie and Bob made sure everything ran smoothly as I am on the east coast and care coordination was difficult to manage for me. Thank you both again for all you have done for my sister and our family during this difficult time.
Professionally, ACMS has such integrity in the services they offer. Care Managers are service oriented. This has been a positive experience in the world of senior health care!
I own two assisted living homes in the area and have worked with Bonnie, Bob and their staff several times. They always have the best interest of their client in mind when finding a long term solution for the family. It has always been my pleasure to accept one of their clients into my home. They continue to stay in touch with the family and assist them with any need they might have.If you are in need of an Elder Care advisor, I wholeheartedly recommend Arizona Care Management Solutions! If you live out of our area, you can count on them to fill in when you can't be here in person!
I live in Massachusetts and my 92 year old dad lived in Sedona. I was called in to take over his care because he could no longer live independently. I literally did not know where to turn. A social worker recommended Bonnie and her team to me. What a relief. They helped me get the necessary paperwork to handle his affairs while also finding him a safe and loving environment where he got the care he needed. He thrived there for nearly 6 months. During that time, I was kept abreast of his health and care by Holly. He enjoyed his visits with her and the treats she brought with her! I highly recommend Arizona Care Management to anyone needing help with their loved ones. They are excellent and I’m so glad they were recommended to me.
As the owners of GENERATIONS SENIOR LIVING LLC, we have the opportunity to work with Bonnie, Bob and the rest of the team at AZ Care Management Solutions with some frequency. Bonnie is absolutely the hardest working person we know! She has the knowledge base and the support team behind her to truly advocate for your loved one and they do a very good job! From assisting with POA paperwork, in-home care, assisting with MD appointments, or actual placement of your family member into a facility...... these guys can get it done!!! We highly recommend them.... Josh and Jamie Elliott
Most of us do not have any experience or training on how to make decisions or select assisted living accommodations. This group was a life saver in selecting a care giver, legal restructuring and finding a home. This was my first time dealing with dementia and I was guided down the path with their professional staff.
When I was having a hard time getting my dad's assisted living place to respond to his needs Gina stepped in with a firm hand and made things happen on Dad's behalf. She is kind, dedicated, tenacious, and extremely experienced and knowledgeable in this field. Bonnie has helped facilitate communication between me and a family member from whom I am estranged to make sure that all family members have access to the information about Dad that they want to have. AZ Care Management has been absolutely VITAL to me in helping me get difficult things done for Dad. I can't imagine navigating these challenging waters without them.
When our daughter was moved to Cottonwood for more extensive care, my husband and I were not able to travel for frequent dr. visits. We were not able, because we are both in our 80s, to visit as frequently as we wanted. AZ Cares takes her to appointments. They also provide very personable and capable assistants who take her on outings to provide social and emotional support for her in our absence. I cannot praise them enough for the support and help they have given our daughter and us. They are a blessing to us!
Arizona Care Management Solutions did a great job keeping my mom as safe as possible in her home for the last year. Once Gina came on board, she managed to do what I thought would be impossible - she convinced my mom to transition to living arrangements that would provide the care she really needed! Gina held her hand every step of the way, even through some VERY challenging situations. This lady has a heart of gold and can get things done!
As a Geriatrics/Internal Medicine specialist I relied on Bonnie and staffto find the best outpatient care for our patients. Her heart is passionate for the care of our seniors, and regards that as her mission in life. And I wasalways confident that Care Management Solutions would find the bestoptions for our families. God bless her! Dr. Paul C. Hanson of Cottonwood Internal Medicine
Bonnie, Bob and the team at AZ Care Management Solutions simply go above and beyond as advocates for seniors. Whether you may need assistance coordinating care, evaluating local facilities for placement, creating a plan for aging well or many other elder care services, you will find no organization more qualified or prepared to assist you than AZ Care Management Solutions. As a local Medicare insurance broker for several years, it is paramount that my clients have the right people in their corner. I have - and will continue to - recommend Bonnie and Bob and their team to any of my clients without hesitation.